Commentary - OnLine

Commentary
The Essence of Preparation

By Le Minh Phuong (February 16, 2007)



Let’s give a hand to the spirit of Peter Davis’s commentary “How to Break
Out of the Cycle of Preparation.” Yet would we really dare to not write the ten page essay due this week in IBH History? I doubt it.

Grades are a gigantic concern for high school students, especially those striving to fulfill the IB curriculum. Some people are able to have the liberated mindset that “I’m going to school for knowledge, not for grades.” However, such assertive statements are rare.  I understand that the importance of grades has been misunderstood by many high school students, including myself!  Perhaps we should consider the concept of grades in a more optimistic light. The usefulness and purpose of grades should not be rejected simply because students may view them to be nothing more than added pressure. Colleges ask for grades because they are a brief summary of our high school lives.  They are evidence of what we attempted to do and how much effort we put into the work. Without university admission staff using grades as evidence and measurement, how will kids end up in the colleges that best fit them?

Although we may be willing to break out, the path to do so is not always so clear.  If we lose interest and connection with the disciplines that we study, problems will inevitably arise and we will never make any progress. We may be motivated today to thoroughly consider the best method to deal with related rates problems, but tomorrow, when another chapter to read for English, another lab to write for Chemistry, and another basketball game to attend fill up space in our agendas, we won’t want to revisit the Calculus notes we took yesterday. This is where grades come in.  Grades represent the contract by which we bind ourselves to do our assignments.  To avoid receiving an “F” on our record, we feel that we’d better finish the work tonight.

One of my favorite rules about life is pretty similar to the ideology of the “Cycle of Preparation,” but I consider it to be more like a domino principle. It’s part of the beauty of nature: the past always leaves us precious privileges that function as the base to reach farther and higher in the present. We are really lucky to undergo these thirteen years of preparation.  Just consider not having the opportunity to prepare. Wouldn’t that be disastrous? Preparation is an important step in the process and is crucial to success. We enter school not even knowing what the alphabet is, yet thanks to the arduous preparation we’ve endured, we leave with the ability to create masterpieces. Preparation pays off.     

Compared with Asia’s educational system, the approach in the United States strongly stresses real-world applications. In American textbooks, the introductions at the beginning of each chapter contain relatively helpful connections with the practical world, while Asian math textbooks, with numbers and more numbers, rarely look attractive and hardly go beyond two hundred pages.  With eye-catching arrangements and sufficient explanations, the textbooks do everything they should to please and teach students at the same time.  

I applaud “How to Break Out of the Cycle of Preparation” because it echoes the spirit of young people who make serious efforts to transform this flawed world. However, transforming this cycle requires a great deal of thought and consideration.  And, if we ever do “break out,” we should always preserve this principle of deliberation so that we do not make changes that we will later regret.


Tell us what you think.  E-mail lassogmhs@hotmail.com